Rachele Ricceri, The Database of Byzantine Book Epigrams: Getting People In and Out Again

This lecture will be given at the PROSOPON Workshop ‘Entangled Prosopographies: Connecting the “Prosopographies of the Later Roman and Byzantine Worlds” Across the Eastern Mediterranean and Beyond’ (The University of Edinburgh, 8-9 December 2023). It is part of Round Table 2: ‘Archives and Manuscripts’.

The workshop brings together a large number of current prosopographical research projects with a focus from the late antique to the late Byzantine periods and is dedicated to exploring ways of going forward, connecting projects and researchers. It offers ample opportunity to discuss the methods and practices of prosopographical research, to learn from each other, and develop closer ties of cooperation.

Practical information

Date & time: Friday 8 December 2023, 1:30pm

Location: Meadows Lecture Theatre, Old Medical School, Doorway 4 (Teviot Place, Edinburgh)

More information about this conference and the full programme can be found here.

Maxime Deforche, An Orthographic Similarity Measure for Graph-based Text Representation

Abstract

Computing the orthographic similarity between words, sentences, paragraphs and texts has become a basic functionality of many text mining and flexible querying systems and the resulting similarity scores are often used to discover similar text documents. However, when dealing with a corpus that is inherently known for its orthographic inconsistencies and intricate interconnected nature on multiple levels (words, verses and full texts), as is the case with Byzantine book epigrams, this task becomes complex. In this paper, we propose a technique that tackles these two challenges by representing text in a graph and by computing a similarity score between multiple levels of the text, modelled as subgraphs, in a hierarchical manner. The similarity between all words is computed first, followed by the calculation of the similarity between all verses (resp. full texts) by using the formerly determined similarity scores between the words (resp. verses). The resulting similarities, on each level, allow for a deeper insight into the interconnected nature in (parts of) text collections, indicating how and to what degree the texts are related to each other.

Practical information

This lecture will be presented at the 15th Internation Conference on Flexible Query Answering Systems.

Date & time: Wednesday 6 September 2023, 12:00 pm

Location: Campus Universitat de les Illes Balears (Carretera de Valldemossa, km 7.5, Palma de Mallorca)

Colin Swaelens, Ilse De Vos & Els Lefever, Medieval Social Media: Manual and Automatic Annotation of Byzantine Greek Marginal Writing

Abstract

In this paper, we present the interim results of a transformer-based annotation pipeline for Ancient and Medieval Greek. As the texts in the Database of Byzantine Book Epigrams have not been normalised, they pose more challenges for manual and automatic annotation than Ancient Greek, normalised texts do. As a result, the existing annotation tools perform poorly. We compiled three data sets for the development of an automatic annotation tool and carried out an inter-annotator agreement study, with a promising agreement score. The experimental results show that our part-of-speech tagger yields accuracy scores that are almost 50 percentage points higher than the widely used rule-based system Morpheus. In addition, error analysis revealed problems related to phenomena also occurring in current social media language.

Practical information

This paper will be presented at “The 61st Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics” (Toronto, 9-14 July 2023). It is part of “The 17th Linguistic Annotation Workshop“.

Linguistic annotation of natural language corpora is the backbone of supervised methods of statistical natural language processing. The Linguistic Annotation Workshop (LAW) is the annual workshop of the ACL Special Interest Group on Annotation (SIGANN), and it provides a forum for the presentation and discussion of innovative research on all aspects of linguistic annotation, including the creation and evaluation of annotation schemes, methods for automatic and manual annotation, use and evaluation of annotation software and frameworks, representation of linguistic data and annotations, semi-supervised “human in the loop” methods of annotation, crowd-sourcing approaches, and more. As in the past, the LAW will provide a forum for annotation researchers to work towards standardization, best practices, and interoperability of annotation information and software.

Date & time: Thursday 13 July 2023; 09:45 am

Location: Westin Harbour Castle (1 Harbour Square, Toronto)

Maxime Deforche, Ilse De Vos & Colin Swaelens, From Umbrellas to Nodes. The Ever-Evolving Database of Byzantine Book Epigrams

Abstract

The Database of Byzantine Book Epigrams (DBBE) at Ghent University contains over 12.000 unique epigrams. They are stored both as occurrences – the epigrams exactly as they occur in the manuscripts – and as types – normalised versions of the occurrences in terms of spelling.

The relationship between occurrences and types is not one-to-one. For example, type 2148 represents 70 two-verse occurrences of the ὥσπερ ξένοι epigram which was used widely by scribes to mark their joy of having reached the end of the manuscript 4 and thus of their copying task. The decision to link multiple occurrences to a single type was both pragmatic and conceptual. Creating fewer types not only freed up time to trace new occurrences, it was also by far the most straightforward way to group similar occurrences. As such, types became umbrellas.

Soon however, this all-or-nothing system ran against its limitations: What exactly does “similar” mean? How “similar” do occurrences need to be for them to be put under the same type? The ὥσπερ ξένοι epigram for example circulated in many different versions, some counting three or four verses. To deal with this variety, increasingly more types were created, each of them covering different subsets of occurrences. To (re)connect these subsets, a complementary system was introduced allowing to link individual verses regardless of the type their occurrence belongs to. As for the ὥσπερ ξένοι epigram, no less than 202 instances of its first verse are to be found in DBBE.

Although a huge step forward, this system still treats similarity as a dichotomy whereas it clearly is a continuum. Also, it does not allow to visualise variation within the more complex lists of “similar” verses nor to take into account different parameters, both textual and other.

A state of the art graph database will offer a versatile and highly visual alternative to the current static representation and rigid treatment of the data, which is inextricably linked to the fact that underlying the user interface is a traditional relational database consisting of tables. A graph database on the contrary can be modelled to efficiently represent the similarity between all epigrams and verses. Instead of using dedicated pieces of data as umbrellas, similar occurrences can be found by simply retrieving a group of nodes – the building stones of a graph database – and the relationships between them. Moreover, it can do so based on any kind of criteria available in the graph, including metadata such as author, time, and place.

In order to maximise the benefits of shifting to such a graph database, it is necessary to enrich the existing data. Therefore, a linguistic pipeline is being developed to perform automatic tokenisation, morphological analysis, and lemmatisation of the entire DBBE corpus. These linguistic annotations will push forward the ways in which similarity can be calculated, far beyond the current level of orthography. The results of the experiments carried out so far are highly promising. Does this mean the end for the types? Quite the contrary. We will always need types as readable representatives of occurrences. The less we need them as umbrellas, the more they can be just that.

Practical information

This lecture will be given at the international workshop “Repetition and Ritual, Text and Edition, Challenges and Solutions”  (Austrian Academy of Sciences, 24-25 November 2022). The workshop is organised by Eirini Afentoulidou in the framework of the project “Female Identities at a Liminal State: An Analysis of Childbed Prayers in Byzantine Prayerbooks”.

Date & time: Friday 25 November 2022, 9:30 am

Location: Austrian Academy of Sciences, Institute for Medieval Research (Hollandstraße 11-13, 1020 Vienna) & Zoom (pre-registration is mandatory for the online event; please contact: ekaterini.mitsiou@oeaw.ac.at)

 

Rachele Ricceri, ‘Text and Image, Text as Image: The Beauty of the Book in Byzantine Book Epigrams’

Abstract

Book epigrams, or metrical paratexts, abound in Byzantine manuscripts. These compositions are the joining link between verse inscriptions, written on any kind of support, and manuscript anthologies, which transmit literary epigrams. Byzantine book epigrams have been collected in an online Database (DBBE, www.dbbe.ugent.be), hosted by Ghent University, with the scope of gathering and making available a large corpus of metrical paratexts dating up to the 15th century.

This paper offers some reflections on the aesthetics of books as presented in book epigrams. In the first part of the lecture I will present some epigrams that clearly refer to the physical or spiritual beauty of the book in which they are inscribed.

Moreover, I will discuss some book epigrams potentially dealing with images in their double function of pieces of poetry and of “objects” themselves. Firstly, metrical captions frequently explain, comment upon and enhance the presence of manuscript miniatures. These captions are often clustered in cycles that appear in one or more manuscripts featuring similar miniatures. Secondly, epigrams can also replace miniatures and perform a peculiar visual function. Book epigrams can be placed where manuscript miniatures might be expected to be found and describe miniatures that are actually not present in the manuscript.

The relationship between text and image in book epigrams is a bidirectional one. This fluid interrelation make metrical paratexts a particularly suitable corpus to investigate how words and images coexist on the manuscript folio.

Practical information

This lecture will be given at the international conference “Versus ad picturas. Text/Image Relationship in Greek, Latin and Arabic poetry between Late Antiquity and the Middle Ages” (University of Strasbourg, 28-30 September 2022). It is part of the session “Culture grecque. Antiquité tardive et littérature byzantine”.

The conference Versus ad picturas, conceived within the framework of the research of the international group GIRPAM on Greek and Latin poetry in Late Antiquity and the Middle Ages and in particular the activities of the Gutenberg Chair 2021 on biblical poetry, aims to contribute to the study of the relationship between the images we now call artistic, painted on walls, fabrics, stained glass or parchments, and the verses that often accompany them materially or ideally, and that are now increasingly recognized as indispensable to their cultural understanding and social location.

Date & time: Thursday 29 September 2022, 10:00 am

Location: the lecture will be broadcast via streaming: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/84177136590?pwd=ZXV1YVBLYUQzM1hBdVNiSmlIS0U1Zz09

  • Meeting ID: 841 7713 6590
  • Passcode: 754872

More information about this conference and the full programme can be found here.

Julián Bértola, Towards a Reassessment of Ephraim of Ainos

From 9 to 11 February 2022, Krystina Kubina convenes a conference on “Poetry in Late Byzantium” within the framework of her project at the Department of Byzantine Research (Austrian Academy of Sciences) devoted to the same topic. During these three days, more than 30 scholars from across the world will discuss forms, functions and developments of this important aspect of medieval Greek literature.

The programme can be found here.

The DBBE will be represented by Julián Bértola, who will give a talk entitled “Towards a Reassessment of Ephraim of Ainos”.

 

Practical information

Date & time: Thursday 10 February 2022, 14:15 CET

Location: Institute for Medieval Research, Division of Byzantine Research (Hollandstrasse 11-13, 1020 Vienna) and/or online via Zoom.
Pre-registration is mandatory for participating online; please contact krystina.kubina@oeaw.ac.at.

Colin Swaelens, You shall know a verse by the company it keeps. Detecting orthographic and semantic similarity between epigrams

The Argentine Committee of Byzantine Studies (CAEBiz) cordially invites you to its Online workshop on Digital Humanities. The meeting will be co-ordinated by José Maksimczuk (Universität Hamburg – CSMC) and Tom Gheldof (KU Leuven) and will take place on FridayMarch 4, 202214.00 CET.

Representing DBBE, Colin Swaelens will give a talk entitled “You shall know a verse by the company it keeps. Detecting orthographic and semantic similarity between epigrams”.

 

Practical information

Date & time: Friday 4 March 2022, 3:45 pm

Location: the workshop will be held via Zoom (no registration is required): https://uni-hamburg.zoom.us/j/66093457970?pwd=N0h3ZjM4VFYzTlFJQWVXVUpUMmxIZz09

  • Meeting ID: 660 9345 7970
  • Passcode: 23868106

Andreas Rhoby, The Vienna Inscriptional Epigrams Project

Andreas Rhoby presents the fourth and concluding volume of the project ‘Byzantinische Epigramme’, which will be published soon by the Verlag der Österreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften. The volume is dedicated to epigrams accompanying miniatures, and is closely related to the Ghent DBBE project.

Abstract

Byzantium plays a vital role for the transmission of ancient, late antique and Medieval Greek texts. Thousands of manuscripts preserved in libraries and collections are full of texts of ancient tragedians, late antique church fathers and particularly of Biblical texts, which represent the lion’s share of transmitted manuscripts. A considerable number of manuscripts, depending on the setting in which they were copied, are equipped with illuminations or various kinds of ornamentation which increase their value. These often very elaborately and colorfully designed depictions are usually accompanied by texts, which, due to not belonging to the main text of the manuscript, are called paratexts. A considerable number of these paratexts are in verse form. Such texts, called book epigrams, fulfill various functions: they explain the depicted scenes, highlight the relationship between the manuscript’s main text and the illumination, or act themselves as images, as for example when the text of the epigram is written in the shape of a cross or inscribed into an ornamental frame. Many of these texts, considered purely on visual grounds, already resemble inscriptions which are preserved on other kinds of surfaces and objects.
The current volume is structured like the preceding three volumes of the series Byzantine epigrams on objects, which have so far presented inscriptional verses on frescoes and mosaics; icons and portable objects; and on stones. The publication’s focus is on critical editions of the texts, (German) translations of the Greek texts, and commentaries. Besides general chapters on the cultural-historical phenomenon of quasi-inscriptional verses in manuscripts, paleography, language etc., almost all the epigrams treated are also depicted in the volume’s collection of plates in order to facilitate study of the original context of the verses.


Practical information

Date & time: Friday 28 October 2016, 2:30 pm

Location: Blandijn, room 110.046 (Blandijnberg 2, 9000 Gent)

Krystina Kubina, The many ways of reading poetry in late Byzantium: Manuel Philes’ laudatory poems

Abstract
In recent years, scholarship has turned its attention to the historical setting, the Sitz im Leben, of Byzantine poetry. In this context, the most prolific poet of the early 14th century, Manuel Philes, was taken into account. However, due to the vast number of texts transmitted under his name (more than 30,000 verses in more than 150 manuscripts!) no attempt has been made to look at the full picture of how his poetry was read. Without aiming at a complete evaluation, I shall offer an overview of the ways of reception. Philes’ poems were read in a variety of different contexts: from private readings of verse letters over performed enkomia to epigrams inscribed on public buildings. The form of reception also altered the way of how Philes was perceived as an author: from self-conscious reflections of an authorial ‘I’ in letters to the total absence of the author in inscriptions. The example of Manuel Philes shows the wide presence of poetry (and literature in general) in Late Byzantine society.

About the speaker
Krystina Kubina is a doctoral candidate at the University of Vienna working on encomiastic poetry of the early Palaiologan period and visiting scholar at the Ghent Database of Byzantine Book Epigrams project.


Practical information

Date & time: Monday 5 December 2016, 2:30 pm

Location: Blandijn, room 100.043 (Blandijnberg 2, 9000 Gent)

Anna Gialdini, Negotiating “Greekness” in Early Modern Italian Book Production

Abstract

In the mid-fifteenth century, as Italian book collectors began being exposed to Byzantine codices, the bindings of the latter started being imitated in Florence and Venice. The resulting bindings were often hybrid, since they mixed Western and Byzantine techniques, but also distinctly and deliberately “Greek-looking”; they were called “alla greca” and were sought-after for the messages they conveyed: an association with Greek culture; a refined taste for beautifully-bound books; and the appropriation of the Byzantine legacy.

My paper today looks at some aspects of the production and consumption of “alla greca” bookbindings in early modern Italy, and namely the ethnicity of bookbinders and patrons, bookmaking techniques, and collecting practices, and what they tell us about the intellectual milieux in which the books themselves circulated.​

About the speaker:

Anna Gialdini has a BA and MA in Classics from the University of Milan and a Diploma in Archival Studies from the State Archive of Milan. She has recently submitted her PhD thesis on Greek-style Bookbindings in Renaissance Venice, which constitutes an analysis of these objects from a structural and cultural perspective. Her research, which has been supported by the Gladys Krieble Delmas Foundation, the Fondazione Fedrigoni – Istocarta, and the Bibliographical Society of America, also deals with archival bindings, the social history of bookbinders, cross-cultural contact in the early modern Mediterranean, and the materiality of the book in professional contexts. After a short-term fellowship at the Huntington Library, she is now collaborating with the Public Library and Groeningemuseum in Bruges for an exhibition on Colard Mansion and the printing of incunables in the city.


Practical information

Date & time: Wednesday 16 August 2017

Location: Blandijn, room 120.043 (Blandijnberg 2, 9000 Gent)